Thou shalt not put people on ridiculous pedestals no matter how great they are or were.

Theists often try to discredit the ideas of prominent scientists, philosophers, debaters, and orators by finding some flaw in their personality.

But putting people on pedestals of perfection is a theistic notion.
People aren’t perfect.
But when they say/do/discover something correct then it goes beyond that person. Credit for saying/doing/discovering but that doesn’t mean we think of them as infallible.

The only way I can do this is probably by example and critical review..

Dawkins
Brilliant biologist. Derivative philosopher. Often strawmanned in the press. Fairly boring but makes some good points which need to be said.

Gervais
Awful comedian. Succinct atheist. A necessary annoyance.

Harris
Takes a long time to say the bloody obvious. But at least he’s saying it.

Newton
A brilliant mind, capable of so much more had he not been a drunk and a theist. Imagine if he’d not concluded that angels kept the solar system on track..

Hitler
Terrible person, misguided and twisted. Very good artist.

Jesus
Whilst his story is mostly fallacious there are nuggets of good in there. He was written as far from perfect, but we can learn lessons from teachings attributed to him, Ghandi, Buddha and many other spiritual philosophers.

Hitchens
Great oratory skills. Brilliant investigative journalism. Occasionally, brazenly, unashamedly hypocritical.
I only discovered him after I became an active atheist and antitheism became something major in my life, but I can understand how he’d be very influential to the burgeoning atheist mind.

The upshot of all this is;
Whilst we may praise certain aspects of people, this does not mean we condone or praise every action or thought of that person. Making someone a hero is tricky. No one is perfect. No one was perfect. Because our measures are what we as individuals consider perfect. Take the good even if that person was bad.
Does Watkins doing the detestable things he did make the Lost Prophets any less musically talented? No.
People can be capable of being good, bad, influential, brilliant, and boring.
Welcome to the diversity of human personality and potential 🙂

Advertisements

About (V)nemoni)(s

The views and opinions expressed here are purely my own. I am not affiliated with and business or political body. All content is either my own work, items in the public domain, or items used under the terms of Fair Usage for criticism, commentary, or education purposes. (Also; only a fool would take anything posted on here seriously.)
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s